Racked is no longer publishing. Thank you to everyone who read our work over the years. The archives will remain available here; for new stories, head over to Vox.com, where our staff is covering consumer culture for The Goods by Vox. You can also see what we’re up to by signing up here.
[Images via WallyG's amazing Flickr set]
Since it's beginning to look a lot like Christmas, let's turn our attention to the Bergdorf Goodman holiday windows, which have been the source of bloggy controversy for weeks now. Among the anti-fans, Gothamist called the windows "creepy" and New York magazine found them puzzling. But it's Modelizing who seemed most disappointed:
This was just an unexpected fail. After a lot of thinking, I decided why I felt the windows weren't good. They look dated. Something I would have seen 10 years ago from the mannequins to the styling to the over-extravagance but without being extravagant in any way. Does that make sense? There is nothing I want or desire from the windows, no "ah ha!" moment. Lackluster clutter might be the best term to describe it.
It's a harsh assessment, and certainly plenty of window-gazers (Glam Chic and the craftblog Quaint Homemade, for example) wouldn't agree. But it also provides an answer to the question posed by the always-opinionated Shophound, who asked: "Who could resist a window featuring shrubbery made from macaroons? " Apparently, a lot of people.
· Bergdorf Goodman's Creepy Holiday Windows [Gothamist]
· Holiday Windows Take Turn Toward the Trippy [NYMag]
· Bergdorf Goodman x Christmas part 2 [Modelizing]
· Bergdorf Goodman's Seasonal Spree [The Shophound]